• Joe & Kathleen
    • About Joe & Kathleen
    • JoeCamp.info
    • Living Life With Purpose, On Purpose
    • Geezer Breaks Wild Mustang!
    • The Soul of a Horse: The Ultimate Love Story
    • Why I Love God and C.S. Lewis
    • Trust Yourself to Try and Err
    • How Did Dog Movies Turn into Horse Books?
    • On Changing the World…
    • The Birthplace of The Soul of a Horse
    • Our New Place in Middle Tennessee
    • Hear Joe’s Keynote Speech: Dare to Dream
    • Read Chapters 1-4 of The Soul of a Horse
    • More About Joe Camp
  • https://thesoulofahorse.com/dating-as-a-single-mom/
    • singles in des moines
    • ukraine single mothers
    • Promises Made to Our Horses
    • Our Vet Had Never Seen a Baby Like This One
    • Born Wild – The Book
    • Choosing a Lifestyle for Your Horse
    • Confinement Weakens Bones in Horses
    • Why Are These Horses Eating Hay?
    • Respect the Power of the Horse’s Instincts
    • Lessons from the Wild
    • Best Essential Minerals for Horses
    • The Gift of Barefoot
    • Our Paddocks Paradise
    • The BLM Makes It Personal
    • Mind Boggling: This Life with Two Very Special Mustangs
    • For Beginners Only
    • Let Your Horse Be Your Teacher
    • How Can This National Champion Jumper Be Barefoot?
    • Powerful Stories from Happier Healthier Horses Around the World
    • Horses Need Choices
    • Five Undeniable Truths About Horses
  • Blog
    • Current Post
    • Favorite Posts
    • Favorite Photos
    • Trust Yourself to Try and Err
    • How Did Dog Movies Turn into Horse Books?
    • Living Life With Purpose, On Purpose
  • Video
  • Resources
  • JoeCamp.info
    • Joe Camp’s Official Website
    • What God Allows in His Providence Often Seems to Contradict His Purpose
    • Benji Trivia and Film History
    • Brandon Camp Talks About His Dad and Benji
    • Trailer for the New Benji Movie
    • The Logic of Christianity
    • Schools That Excel – How Do They Do It?
    • And More!
  • Best Treats
    • Why Is This Treat So Good For Your Horse?
    • They Say My Standards Are Too High
    • Omega Nibblers-Low Sugar Treats
    • Joe Speaks Out for Dogs
    • Why Supplement?
    • The Best Omega 3s Money Can Buy For Your Horse
    • Omega 3s Are Essential for your Horse
    • Omega Horseshine
    • All The Good Stuff
    • Our Horses Don’t Just Shine On The Outside
  • Health
    • Take Charge of Your Health!
    • “Arthritis is an easy fix…”
    • Best Essential Minerals for Horses
    • Best Essential Minerals for People
    • Why Are These Minerals so Important?
    • Youngevity’s Humic Shale Mine in Utah
    • Bloomin Minerals Videos
    • Bloomin Minerals Feeding Guide
    • Why I Love God and C.S. Lewis
    • Excellent Videos
    • On Changing the World
    • We Feed Ourselves Like We Feed Our Horses
  • Wild Horses
    • Born Wild – The Book
    • How to Save America’s Wild Horses
    • Our First Mustang
    • Judge Collyer’s Ruling Against the BLM re Removal of the West Douglas Herd in Colorado
    • The Soul of a Horse Foundation
      • Wild Horses: Definitely a Native Species
      • Born Wild – The Book
      • Analysis of the Language of the 1971 Law
      • Happier Healthier Horses Around the World
      • How to Save America’s Wild Horses
    • The BLM Makes It Personal
    • Analysis of the Language of the 1971 Law
    • Lessons from the Wild
    • The Wild Free Roaming Horse and Burro Act of 1971
    • Wild Horse Links, Advocates, Videos
    • Chronology of the Horse’s Evolution
    • Wild Horses: Definitely a Native Species
  • Store
  • Contact
  • HOME
  • MEET OUR HORSES
  • THE BOOKS OF JOE CAMP
    • The Books of Joe Camp
    • Love Your Horse First – For Beginners Only
    • The Soul of a Horse – Life Lessons from the Herd
    • Born Wild – The Journey Continues
    • God Only Knows – Can You Trust Him with the Secret?
    • Training with Treats
    • Horses & Stress – Eliminating the Root Cause of Most Health, Hoof, and Behavior Problems
    • Why Relationship First Works
    • Beginning Ground Work
    • Why Our Horses Are Barefoot
    • Horses Were Born to be on Grass
    • Horses Without Grass
    • DOG STORIES – Everything You Need To Know About Life Is Right There At Your Feet
    • The Soul a Horse Blogged
    • The Benji Method – Teach Your Dog To Do What Benji Does in the Movies
    • Who Needs Hollywood
    • Hear Joe’s Keynote Speech: Dare to Dream
    • Read Chapters 1-4 of The Soul of a Horse
    • Reviews of Joe’s Books
    • How Did Dog Movies Turn into Horse Books?
    • Living Life With Purpose, On Purpose
    • About Joe Camp
  • LIFESTYLE
    • Lifestyle
    • Our Vet Had Never Seen a Baby Like This One
    • Born Wild – The Book
    • Choosing a Lifestyle for Your Horse
    • Confinement Weakens Bones in Horses
    • Winter Reminders – Water That Doesn’t Freeze, and More
    • No More Blankets – An Amazing Article
    • Respect the Power of the Horse’s Instincts
    • Trust Yourself to Try and Err
    • Why Bitless?
    • ukraine single mothers
    • Why Are These Horses Eating Hay?
    • Even Non-GMO is Not Necessarily Safe
    • Promises Made to Our Horses
    • Lessons from the Wild
    • What’s In It for the Horse?
    • Trust – It Changes Everything
    • Best Essential Minerals for Horses
    • For Beginners Only
    • On Changing the World…
    • We Feed Ourselves Like We Feed Our Horses
    • Domestic Horses and the Wild Horse Lifestyle
    • Myth #1
    • The Gift of Barefoot
    • Let Your Horse Be Your Teacher
    • How Can This National Champion Jumper Be Barefoot?
    • The Soul of a Horse: The Ultimate Love Story
    • Five Undeniable Truths About Horses
    • Horses Need Choices
    • Our Paddocks Paradise
    • The Truth About Your Horses’ Teeth
    • Fear, Faith & Abscesses
    • Age 6 = Physical Maturity
    • No More Poison – Life Without De-Wormers
    • No More Salt Blocks
    • Horses & Stress
    • Why the Wild Horse Model?
    • Mind Boggling: This Life with Two Very Special Mustangs
    • Powerful Stories from Happier Healthier Horses Around the World
    • Diet & Nutrition
    • Horses Were Born to be on Grass
    • Horses Without Grass
    • Read Chapters 1-4 of The Soul of a Horse
    • About Joe Camp
  • LIBERTY
    • Liberty Inspires Trust
    • No Strings Attached
    • Mind Boggling: Life at Liberty with Two Very Special Mustangs
    • For Beginners Only
    • Born Wild – The Book
    • Geezer Breaks Wild Mustang!
    • Trust Yourself to Try and Err
    • How to Catch Your Horse in the Pasture – A Guaranteed Method
    • Lessons from the Wild
    • How Can This National Champion Jumper Be Barefoot?
    • Let Your Horse Be Your Teacher
    • Trust – It Changes Everything
    • On Changing the World…
    • Powerful Stories from Happier Healthier Horses Around the World
    • Myth #1
    • Trust Yourself to Try and Err
    • The Soul of a Horse: The Ultimate Love Story
    • Read Chapters 1-4 of The Soul of a Horse
    • About Joe Camp
  • RELATIONSHIP
    • Relationship
    • Leadership Second
    • Relationship with Two Very Special Mustangs
    • No-Agenda Time
    • Trust – It Changes Everything
    • How to Catch Your Horse in the Pasture – A Guaranteed Method
    • See the Difference Relationship Makes
    • Why Bitless?
    • Our First Mustang-At Long, Long Last!
    • Trust Yourself to Try and Err
    • Best Essential Minerals for Horses
    • For Beginners Only
    • Living Life With Purpose, On Purpose
    • How Did Dog Movies Turn into Horse Books?
    • Lessons from the Wild
    • Born Wild – The Book
    • The Soul of a Horse: The Ultimate Love Story
    • The BLM Makes It Personal
    • Let Your Horse Be Your Teacher
    • On Changing the World…
    • We Feed Ourselves Like We Feed Our Horses
    • Geezer Breaks Wild Mustang!
    • Relationship and Training Resources
    • What’s In It for the Horse?
    • The Gift of Barefoot
    • Trust Yourself to Try and Err
    • How Can This National Champion Jumper Be Barefoot?
    • Powerful Stories from Happier Healthier Horses Around the World
    • Training with Treats
    • Meet Our Horses
    • Myth #1
    • Horses & Stress
    • Relationship Links and Resources
    • Why Relationship First Works
    • Beginning Ground Work
    • Read Chapters 1-4 of The Soul of a Horse
    • About Joe Camp
  • BARE FEET
    • Why Barefoot?
    • The Gift of Barefoot
    • Barefoot Champions
      • Photos of Barefoot Champions
      • How Can This National Champion Jumper Be Barefoot?
    • The Houston Mounted Police Patrol-Barefoot and Bitless
    • Lessons from the Wild
    • Confinement Weakens Bones in Horses
    • ukraine single mothers
    • Why Bitless?
    • For Beginners Only
    • Choosing a Lifestyle for Your Horse
    • Best Essential Minerals for Horses
    • We Feed Ourselves Like We Feed Our Horses
    • Invite Joe to Your Meeting
    • Born Wild – The Book
    • 5 Undeniable Truths
    • Barefoot Videos
    • Powerful Stories from Happier Healthier Horses Around the World
    • Horses & Stress
    • On Changing the World…
    • Fear, Faith & Abscesses
    • Find a Trimmer
    • 10 Questions Before Hiring a Trimmer
    • Barefoot Links and Resources
    • Read Chapters 1-4 of The Soul of a Horse
  • HORSEMANSHIP
    • Horsemanship
    • Relationship First
    • Leadership Second
    • No Agenda Time – Join Up Without a Round Pen
    • See the Difference Relationship Makes
    • Our Vet Had Never Seen a Baby Like This One
    • Trust Yourself to Try and Err
    • Lessons from the Wild
    • Confinement Weakens Bones in Horses
    • Winter Reminders – Water That Doesn’t Freeze, and More
    • No More Blankets – An Amazing Article
    • How to Catch Your Horse in the Pasture – A Guaranteed Method
    • Trust – It Changes Everything
    • ukraine single mothers
    • We Feed Ourselves Like We Feed Our Horses
    • Geezer Breaks Wild Mustang!
    • For Beginners Only
    • Respect the Power of the Horse’s Instincts
    • Born Wild – The Book
    • The BLM Makes It Personal
    • Let Your Horse Be Your Teacher
    • Relationship and Training Resources
    • Myth #1
    • What’s In It for the Horse?
    • No Horse is Skeletally Mature Before 5.5- to 6 Years Old
    • How Can This National Champion Jumper Be Barefoot?
    • Training with Treats
    • Trust Yourself to Try and Err
    • Lifestyle
    • Liberty
    • Diet
    • Mind Boggling: This Life with Two Very Special Mustangs
    • Powerful Stories from Happier Healthier Horses Around the World
    • Meet Our Horses
    • Why Bitless?
    • The Gift of Barefoot
    • Choosing a Lifestyle for Your Horse
    • Our Paddocks Paradise
    • On Changing the World…
    • The Soul of a Horse: The Ultimate Love Story
    • Read Chapters 1-4 of The Soul of a Horse
    • About Joe Camp
  • DIET
    • Diet
    • For Beginners Only
    • ukraine single mothers
    • Why Are These Horses Eating Hay?
    • Even Non-GMO is Not Necessarily Safe
    • Lessons from the Wild
    • Best Essential Minerals for Horses
    • Horses Need Choices
    • Respect the Power of the Horse’s Instincts
    • On Changing the World…
    • We Feed Ourselves Like We Feed Our Horses
    • The Gift of Barefoot
    • Trust Yourself to Try and Err
    • Invite Joe to Your Meeting
    • No More Poison – Life Without De-Wormers
    • No More Salt Blocks
    • The Truth About Your Horses’ Teeth
    • Fear, Faith & Abscesses
    • How Can This National Champion Jumper Be Barefoot?
    • Choosing a Lifestyle for Your Horse
    • Horses & Stress
    • Powerful Stories from Happier Healthier Horses Around the World
    • Read Chapters 1-4 of The Soul of a Horse
    • About Joe Camp
  • Subscribe to our email Newsletter
  • Read About Benji
  • View New Benji Movie Trailer
  • About Joe Camp
  • Press Room
  • How to Save America’s Wild Horses
  • Read About Happier Healthier Horses Across the Planet
  • Join Our Affiliate Program
  • Read About The Houston Mounted Police Patrol All Barefoot
Fish
TSOAH Born Wild Cover Horses & Stress TSOAHB - Cover Dog Stories God Only Knows Why Relationship First Works Beginning Ground Work Why Barefoot? Treats Horses Were Born-Grass Horses Without Grass TeleWorkshops Widget Who Needs Hollywood The Benji Method Promise Book #1
  • Articles by Joe – Non-Horsey But Passionate
  • Q&A with Joe
  • Our Former Place – The Birthplace of The Soul of a Horse
  • Our New Place in Middle Tennessee
  • Television & Radio Interviews
  • Read About the Houston Mounted Police Patrol – 40 Horses Working the Streets – All Barefoot!
  • Jack L. Kennedy Reviews Joe’s Books
  • The Soul of a Horse on Facebook

Recent Posts

  • Why Are These Horses Eating Hay?

Archives

  • June 2017
  • Website Home
  • Blog Home
  • About Joe & Kathleen
  • Meet Our Horses
  • The Books of Joe Camp
    • How Did Dog Movies Turn into Horse Books?
    • Reviews of Joe’s Books
    • The Soul of a Horse – Life Lessons from the Herd
    • The Soul of a Horse Blogged: The Journey Continues
    • eBook Nuggets from The Soul of a Horse
      • Why Relationship First Works
      • Beginning Ground Work
      • Why Our Horses Are Barefoot
      • Training with Treats
      • Horses Were Born to be on Grass
      • Horses Without Grass
  • Why the Wild Horse Model?
    • Our Paddocks Paradise
    • Horses Need Choices
    • Five Undeniable Truths About Horses
  • Lifestyle
    • Diet & Nutrition
    • Why Barefoot?
    • Five Undeniable Truths About Horses
  • Relationship
    • Leadership Second
    • Training with Treats
    • Meet Our Horses
    • Relationship Links and Resources
  • Bare Feet
    • 10 Questions Before Hiring a Trimmer
    • 5 Undeniable Truths
    • The Gift of Barefoot
    • Barefoot Links & Resources
    • Barefoot Videos
    • Find a Trimmer
  • Diet
  • Why Bitless?
  • Take this Stress Test
  • Our Paddocks Paradise
  • How to Save America’s Wild Horses
  • The Store
  • Photos of Barefoot Champions
  • Contact

Judge Collyer’s Ruling Against the BLM re Removal of the West Douglas Herd in Colorado

All bold facing and underlining is mine, to be sure you didn’t miss it – Joe Camp

Case 1:06-cv-01609-RMC Document 105 Filed 08/05/2009

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THE DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA

COLORADO WILD HORSE AND
BURRO COALITION, INC., et al.,
Plaintiffs,
v.
KEN SALAZAR, Secretary, U.S.
Department of the Interior,1 et al.,
Defendants.

Civil Action No. 06-1609 (RMC)

MEMORANDUM OPINION
Plaintiffs challenge the decision of the Bureau of Land Management (“BLM”), an agency of the U.S. Department of the Interior, to remove all wild horses from the West Douglas Herd Area in Colorado. They argue, inter alia, that the decision violates the Wild Free-Roaming Horses and Burros Act (“Wild Horse Act” or “Act”), 16 U.S.C. § 1331 et seq. Defendants counter that BLM’s decision to remove the West Douglas Herd is a reasonable exercise of BLM’s discretion and is entitled to Chevron2 deference. Before the Court are cross motions for summary judgment.3 For the reasons explained herein, the Court finds that BLM’s decision to remove the West Douglas Herd exceeds the scope of authority that Congress delegated to it in the Wild Horse Act. The Court will grant in part Plaintiffs’ motion for summary judgment, deny Defendants’ cross motion for summary judgment, and set aside BLM’s decision.

I. FACTS

The West Douglas Herd Area encompasses 123,387 acres of federal land managed by BLM and 4,754 acres of private land in Northwestern Colorado, southwest of the town of Rangely and approximately 50 miles north of Grand Junction. It is located within the White River Resource Area. In the first census conducted by BLM in 1974, it counted 9 wild horses in the West Douglas Herd Area.(5) BLM estimates that there are now 147 wild horses in the herd area.

In 1975, BLM drafted a White River Resource Area Management Framework Plan6 that provided a framework for managing multiple uses in the area, including the management of the wild horses. In 1980, BLM issued an updated Management Framework Plan which recommended that all horses west of Douglas Creek (later designated as the West Douglas Herd Area) be removed because other resource activities in this area (namely, energy exploration) were causing the horses to disperse into areas where they did not roam in 1971, when the Wild Horse Act was enacted. In 1985, for reasons not fully explained, BLM unsuccessfully attempted to completely remove wild horses from the West Douglas Herd Area.

On July 1,1997, the Colorado State Director of BLM signed a Record of Decision for the White River Resource Area Management Plan that called for the total removal of wild horses in the West Douglas Herd Area by 2007. However, BLM decided to reconsider its decision and to conduct further analysis before commencing the removal of the West Douglas Herd.

On April 28, 2005, BLM published an environmental assessment that considered two alternatives: Alternative A, removing all wild horses from the West Douglas Herd Area by 2007; and Alternative B, managing a small herd of 29-60 wild horses in this area. On August 29, 2005, Kent E. Walter, Field Manager for BLM’s White River Field Office, issued a proposed Decision Record and a Finding of No Significant Impact with respect to his decision to implement Alternative A, removing all wild horses from the West Douglas Herd Area. Mr. Walter’s proposed decision was protested by five parties, including counsel for Plaintiffs in this case.

By letters dated October 10, 2007, Bud Cribley, BLM’s Acting Assistant Director for Renewable Resources and Planning, denied each of the five protests to Mr. Walter’s proposed decision to remove all wild horses from the West Douglas Herd Area. Mr. Cribley concluded that the White River Field Office and the Colorado State Director followed the appropriate planning procedures and complied with applicable laws in reaching their decisions. Thereafter, but also on October 10, 2007, the Colorado State Director issued a Decision Record approving Mr. Walter’s proposed decision to remove all of the wild horses in the West Douglas Herd Area “at the earliest date.”

On July 14, 2008, BLM released its 2008 West Douglas Herd Area Wild Horse Removal Final Decision Record and Environmental Assessment (“2008 Gather Plan”), authored by Mr. Walter, which provided that “[a]ll wild horses will be removed from within and outside the [West Douglas Herd Area] beginning no sooner than October 1, 2008” and that “[t]he gather methods used will include helicopter drive trapping, helicopter assisted roping, water trapping, or bait trapping.” See Defs.’ Combined Mem. in Opp’n to Pls.’ Mot. for Summ. J. & in Supp. of Cross-Mot. for Summ. J. [Dkt. # 71], Ex. 1 at 1. However, the gather never occurred due to a lack of funding. See Defs.’ Notice of Postponement of West Douglas Gather [Dkt. # 87]. BLM currently plans to remove 100 horses from the West Douglas Herd Area pursuant to the 2008 Gather Plan beginning on September 27, 2009. See Defs.’ Notice of Intent to Conduct Partial Removal [Dkt. # 97].

Plaintiffs are four associations organized to protect wild horses and one equine veterinarian, a former contract veterinarian for BLM, who frequently visits the West Douglas Herd Area to see and enjoy the wild horses. Plaintiffs filed their Third Amended Complaint on March 24, 2009, seeking, inter alia, a declaration that the 2008 Gather Plan exceeds BLM’s discretion in the Wild Horse Act and an order setting aside the 2008 Gather Plan as ultra vires. Pending before the Court are cross motions for summary judgment.

II. LEGAL STANDARDS

A. Standard of Review

Under the Administrative Procedure Act (“APA”), 5 U.S.C. § 551 et seq., “[a]gency action made reviewable by statute and final agency action for which there is no other adequate remedy in a court are subject to judicial review.”7 Id. § 704. The APA provides that the reviewing court shall “hold unlawful and set aside agency action . . . found to be . . . in excess of statutory jurisdiction, authority, or limitations, or short of statutory right.” Id. § 706(2)(C). “To determine if the Secretary has exceeded his statutory authority under 5 U.S.C. § 706(2)(C), the Court must engage in the two-step inquiry required by Chevron.” Anna Jacques Hosp. v. Leavitt, 537 F. Supp. 2d 24, 29-30 (D.D.C. 2008). “If the intent of Congress is clear, that is the end of the matter; for the court, as well as the agency, must give effect to the unambiguously expressed intent of Congress.” Chevron, 467 U.S. at 842-43. “[I]f the statute is silent or ambiguous with respect to the specific issue, the question for the court is whether the agency’s answer is based on a permissible construction of the statute.” Id. at 843.

B. Summary Judgment Standard

Under Rule 56 of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, summary judgment must be granted when “the pleadings, depositions, answers to interrogatories, and admissions on file, together with the affidavits, if any, show that there is no genuine issue as to any material fact and that the moving party is entitled to a judgment as a matter of law.” Fed. R. Civ. P. 56 (c); Anderson v. Liberty Lobby, Inc., 477 U.S. 242, 247 (1986); see also Celotex Corp. v. Catrett, 477 U.S. 317, 322 (1986); Diamond v. Atwood, 43 F.3d 1538, 1540 (D.C. Cir. 1995). Moreover, summary judgment is properly granted against a party that “after adequate time for discovery and upon motion . . . fails to make a showing sufficient to establish the existence of an element essential to that party’s case, and on which that party will bear the burden of proof at trial.” Celotex, 477 U.S. at 322. To determine which facts are “material,” a court must look to the substantive law on which each claim rests. Anderson, 477 U.S. at 248 (1986). A “genuine issue” is one whose resolution could establish an element of a claim or defense and, therefore, affect the outcome of the action. Celotex, 477 U.S. at 322; Anderson, 477 U.S. at 248.

In ruling on a motion for summary judgment, the court must draw all justifiable inferences in the nonmoving party’s favor and accept the nonmoving party’s evidence as true. Anderson, 477 U.S. at 255. A nonmoving party, however, must establish more than “the mere existence of a scintilla of evidence” in support of its position. Id. at 252. To prevail on a motion for summary judgment, the moving party must show that the nonmoving party “fail[ed] to make a showing sufficient to establish the existence of an element essential to that party’s case, and on which that party will bear the burden of proof at trial.” Celotex, 477 U.S. at 322. By pointing to the absence of evidence proffered by the nonmoving party, a moving party may succeed on summary judgment. Id. In addition, the nonmoving party may not rely solely on allegations or conclusory statements. Greene v. Dalton, 164 F.3d 671, 675 (D.C. Cir. 1999); Harding v. Gray, 9 F.3d 150, 154 (D.C. Cir. 1993). Rather, the nonmoving party must present specific facts that would enable a reasonable jury to find in its favor. Greene, 164 F.3d at 675. If the evidence “is merely colorable, or is not significantly probative, summary judgment may be granted.” Anderson, 477 U.S. at 249-50 (citations omitted).

III. ANALYSIS

A. Standing

Associational Plaintiffs Colorado Wild Horse and Burro Coalition, Inc., American Mustang and Burro Association, Inc., the Cloud Foundation, Inc., and Front Range Equine Rescue, Inc. “have representational standing if: (1) at least one of their members has standing to sue in his or her own right, (2) the interests the association seeks to protect are germane to its purpose, and (3) neither the claim asserted nor the relief requested requires the participation of an individual member in the lawsuit.” Am. Library Ass’n v. FCC, 401 F.3d 489, 492 (D.C. Cir. 2005). Individual Plaintiff Dr. Don Moore and the associational Plaintiffs’ members have constitutional standing to sue if “(1) [they] ha[ve] suffered an ‘injury in fact’ that is (a) concrete and particularized and (b) actual or imminent, not conjectural or hypothetical; (2) the injury is fairly traceable to the challenged action of the defendant; and (3) it is likely, as opposed to merely speculative, that the injury will be redressed by a favorable decision.” Friends of the Earth, Inc. v. Laidlaw Envtl. Servs., 528 U.S. 167, 180-81 (2000) (citing Lujan v. Defenders of Wildlife, 504 U.S. 555, 560-61 (1992)). They have prudential standing if their injury “arguably falls within the zone of interests protected or regulated by the statutory provision or constitutional guarantee invoked in the suit.” Bennett v. Spear, 520 U.S. 154, 162 (1997).

The only real issue is whether Plaintiffs will suffer an injury in fact if the West Douglas Herd is removed.9 “It is clear that the person who observes . . . a particular animal threatened by a federal decision is facing perceptible harm, since the very subject of his interest will no longer exist.” Lujan, 504 U.S. at 566. Such is the case here with respect to individual Plaintiff Dr. Don Moore and associational Plaintiffs Colorado Wild Horse and Burro Coalition, Inc., and American Mustang and Burro Association, Inc. See Pls.’ Mot. for Summ. J. [Dkt. # 68], Ex. 1 (Decl. of Donald E. Moore) ¶ 2 (“Seeing [the West Douglas Herd] in their natural surroundings and running free is essential to the aesthetic enjoyment of these [horseback] trips, which I have been taking for the past 55 years.”); id., Ex. 3 (Decl. of Toni Hutcheson Moore on behalf of Colorado Wild Horse and Burro Coalition, Inc.) ¶ 12 (“Further removals will have a significant impact on me and my family to observe wild horses in the White River Field Office.”); id., Ex. 4 (Decl. of Barbara Flores on behalf of American Mustang and Burro Association, Inc.) ¶ 1 (“An area so rich in wild horse and native American history in such a beautiful setting makes my spirit soar to visit it and catch the now isolated glimpse of the last remaining wild horses in West Douglas.”). Therefore, Plaintiffs have standing to challenge the 2008 Gather Plan.

B. The Wild Horse Act

The Wild Horse Act provides that “Congress finds and declares that wild freeroaming horses and burros are living symbols of the historic and pioneer spirit of the West; that they contribute to the diversity of life forms within the Nation and enrich the lives of the American people; and that these horses and burros are fast disappearing from the American scene.” 16 U.S.C. § 1331. The Act further provides that “[i]t is the policy of Congress that wild free-roaming horses and burros shall be protected from capture, branding, harassment, or death; and to accomplish this they are to be considered in the area where presently found, as an integral part of the natural system of the public lands.”11 Id. It is a federal crime to remove a wild free-roaming horse or burro from public lands, convert a wild free-roaming horse or burro to private use, or kill or harass a wild freeroaming horse or burro. See id. § 1338(a)(1)-(3).

Congress delegated to the Secretary of Agriculture and the Secretary of the Interior jurisdiction over all wild free-roaming horses and burros “for the purpose of management and protection in accordance with the provisions of this chapter.”12 Id. § 1333(a). Section 1333(a) provides that “[t]he Secretary is authorized and directed to protect and manage wild free-roaming horses and burros as components of the public lands, and he may designate and maintain specific ranges on public lands as sanctuaries for their protection and preservation . . . .” Id. It further provides that “[t]he Secretary shall manage wild free-roaming horses and burros in a manner that is designed to achieve and maintain a thriving natural ecological balance on the public lands” and that “[a]ll management activities shall be at the minimal feasible level . . . in order to protect the natural ecological balance of all wildlife species which inhabit such lands, particularly endangered wildlife species.” Id.

Section 1333(b)(1) requires BLM to maintain a current inventory of wild horses and burros so that it can “make determinations as to whether and where an overpopulation exists and whether action should be taken to remove excess animals; determine appropriate management levels of wild free-roaming horses and burros on these areas of public lands; and determine whether appropriate management levels should be achieved by the removal or destruction of excess animals, or other options (such as sterilization, or natural controls on population levels).” Id. § 1333(b)(1). Section 1333(b)(2) provides that when BLM determines “that an overpopulation exists on a given area of the public lands and that action is necessary to remove excess animals, [the Secretary] shall immediately remove excess animals from the range so as to achieve appropriate management levels.” Id. § 1333(b)(2). The term “excess animals” is defined as “wild free-roaming horses or burros (1) which have been removed from an area by the Secretary pursuant to applicable law or, (2) which must be removed from an area in order to preserve and maintain a thriving natural ecological balance and multiple-use relationship in that area.” Id. § 1332(f). (footnoote: The term “range” is defined as “the amount of land necessary to sustain an existing herd or herds of wild free-roaming horses and burros, which does not exceed their known territorial limits, and which is devoted principally but not necessarily exclusively to their welfare in keeping with the multiple-use management concept for the public lands.”)

Section 1333(b)(2) specifically provides an “order and priority” for removal of excess animals “until all excess animals have been removed so as to restore a thriving natural ecological balance to the range, and protect the range from the deterioration associated with overpopulation.”13 Id. § 1333(b)(2). Specifically, it first provides that BLM “shall order old, sick, or lame animals to be destroyed in the most humane manner possible.” Id. § 1333(b)(2)(A). Second, BLM “shall cause such number of additional excess wild free-roaming horses and burros to be humanely captured and removed for private maintenance and care for which [the Secretary] determines an adoption demand exists by qualified individuals . . . .” Id. § 1333(b)(2)(B). Third, and as a last resort, BLM “shall cause additional excess wild free-roaming horses and burros for which an adoption demand by qualified individuals does not exist to be destroyed in the most humane and cost efficient manner possible.” Id. § 1333(b)(2)(C). In § 1333(e), Congress also gave BLM authority to sell any excess animal that is more than 10 years old or that has been offered unsuccessfully for adoption at least three times. See id. § 1333(e)(1).

Congress stipulated five conditions upon which the animals “shall lose their status as wild free-roaming horses or burros and shall no longer be considered as falling within the purview of this chapter.” Id. § 1333(d). The first is if title to an excess animal has passed to a qualified individual for adoption or private maintenance. See id. § 1333(d)(1). The second is if an excess animal has been transferred for private maintenance or adoption and “die[s] of natural causes before passage of tile.” Id. § 1333(d)(2). The third is if an excess animal is destroyed by BLM “pursuant to subsection (b) of this section.” Id. § 1333(d)(3). The fourth is if a wild free-roaming horse or burro dies of natural causes on public lands or private lands where the animal was maintained and BLM has authorized disposal of the animal. See id. § 1333(d)(4). And the fifth is if a wild freeroaming horse or burro is destroyed or dies “for purposes of or incident to the program authorized in this section.”14 Id. § 1333(d)(5). Any excess animal that is sold by BLM pursuant to § 1333(e) also is no longer “considered to be a wild free-roaming horse or burro for the purposes of this chapter.” Id. § 1333(e)(4).

Finally, § 1339, entitled “Limitation of authority,” provides that “[n]othing in this chapter shall be construed to authorize the Secretary to relocate wild free-roaming horses or burros to areas of the public lands where they do not presently exist.” Id.

B. BLM’s Authority to “Manage” Wild Free-Roaming Horses and Burros

Against this backdrop, Defendants take the extreme position that it is within BLM’s discretion to remove the entire West Douglas Herd, a herd comprised of wild free-roaming horses that Defendants conceded at oral argument BLM has not determined to be “excess animals.”15 See Tr. at 6 (“THE COURT: Well, are you saying that the 147 horses in the West Douglas area are excess? MS. FLOOM: No, Your Honor. BLM has – our position is that BLM is not required to make a determination that those horses are excess before removing them from the herd area.”). Defendants assert that implicit in BLM’s authority to “manage” wild free-roaming horses and burros in § 1333(a) is the discretion to remove the very animals that Congress intended to protect in the Wild Horse Act. See id. at 6-7 (“THE COURT: Where do you find authority to remove horses that are not excess? MS. FLOOM: Your Honor, that authority is inherent within BLM’s broad authority to manage horses. . . . Under Section 1333 of the statute, BLM is given broad authority to manage wild horses.”). The Court declines to afford BLM’s interpretation deference. E.g., Am. Horse Prot. Ass’n, Inc. v. Watt, 694 F.2d 1310, 1319 (D.C. Cir. 1982) (noting that under the Wild Horse Act “the Secretary’s discretion remains bounded” and that “[h]is orders are subject to review and may be overturned if his action is arbitrary”).

The initial inquiry under Chevron is “whether Congress has directly spoken to the precise question at issue.” Chevron, 467 U.S. at 842. “If the intent of Congress is clear, that is the end of the matter; for the court, as well as the agency, must give effect to the unambiguously expressed intent of Congress.” Id. at 842-43. However, “if the statute is silent or ambiguous with respect to the specific issue, the question for the court is whether the agency’s answer is based on a permissible construction of the statute.” Id. at 843. The “specific issue” here is not whether BLM may remove an entire herd of wild free-roaming horses and burros, as Defendants assert; the “specific issue” is whether BLM may remove an entire herd of wild free-roaming horses and burros that BLM concededly has not determined to be “excess animals” within the meaning of the Wild Horse Act.16 For the following reasons, the Court finds that Congress clearly intended to protect non-excess wild free-roaming horses and burros from removal, and that BLM’s removal authority is limited to those wild free-roaming horses and burros that it determines to be “excess animals” within the meaning of the Wild Horse Act.17

BLM’s authority to “manage” wild free-roaming horses and burros is expressly made subject to “the provisions of this chapter[,]” 16 U.S.C. § 1333(a), including the provision that “[i]t is the policy of Congress that wild free-roaming horses and burros shall be protected from capture . . . .” Id. § 1331. It would be anomalous to infer that by authorizing the custodian of the wild freeroaming horses and burros to “manage” them, Congress intended to permit the animals’ custodian to subvert the primary policy of the statute by capturing and removing from the wild the very animals that Congress sought to protect from being captured and removed from the wild.

Defendants argue that the horses will not be “eradicated” or “eliminated” inasmuch as BLM intends to continue to manage the horses not in the wild but through private adoption or long-term care. See Answer to 3d Am. Compl. ¶ 2. But BLM’s directive is “to protect and manage wild free-roaming horses and burros as components of the public lands . . . .” 16 U.S.C. § 1333(a) (emphasis added). Congress did not authorize BLM to “manage” the wild horses by corralling them for private maintenance or long-term care as non-wild free-roaming animals off of the public lands. Upon removal for private adoption and/or long-term care, the West Douglas Herd would forever cease to be “wild free-roaming” horses “as components of the public lands” contrary to Congress’s intent to protect the horses from capture.

Moreover, the statute expressly provides that BLM’s “management activities shall be at the minimal feasible level . . . .” Id. (emphasis added). It is difficult to think of a “management activity” that is farther from a “minimal feasible level” than removal. While Congress did not specifically define “manage,” it did provide a list of the “management activities” it envisioned. The management activities that Congress had in mind were for BLM to “make determinations as to whether and where an overpopulation exists and whether action should be taken to remove excess animals; determine appropriate management levels of wild free-roaming horses and burros on these areas of public lands; and determine whether appropriate management levels should be achieved by the removal or destruction of excess animals, or other options (such as sterilization, or natural controls on population levels).” Id. § 1333(b)(1) (emphasis added). Conspicuously omitted from this list is any reference to a determination by BLM to remove non-excess animals.

Further, Congress prescribed a detailed statutory procedure for removing excess animals. See id. § 1333(b)(2)(A)-(C). Congress “specified both the circumstances under which BLM may determine that an overpopulation of wild horses exists and the means the Agency may use to control horse populations.” Am. Horse Protection Ass’n, 694 F.2d at 1316. Yet there is no procedure in the statute for removing non-excess animals. While it is true, as Defendants argue, that nothing in the statute expressly precludes BLM from removing non-excess animals, it would make no sense for Congress to provide detailed procedures for removing excess animals but no procedure at all for removing non-excess animals.18 For this reason, the Court rejects Defendants’ proposed construction that § 1333(b) requires the removal of excess animals whereas § 1333(a) permits the removal of non-excess animals. In light of the statute’s purpose to protect wild free-roaming horses and burros, the Court finds that the only plausible inference to be drawn from the omission of any procedure for removing non-excess animals is that Congress did not intend for BLM’s management authority to be so broad.

This inference is bolstered by the fact that Congress specifically excluded from the Act’s coverage those excess animals that are adopted, sold, or destroyed following removal by BLM pursuant to § 1333(b), see 16 U.S.C. § 1333(d) & (e)(4), but the Act contains no exclusion for the adoption, sale, or destruction of non-excess animals removed by BLM pursuant to § 1333(a), the provision of the statute authorizing BLM to “manage” wild free-roaming horses and burros. In addition, Congress expressly limited BLM’s authority “to relocate wild free-roaming horses or burros to areas of the public lands where they do not presently exist.” Id. § 1339. Given the policy expressed in the statute, it would make no sense to prohibit BLM from relocating wild horses to public lands where they did not historically exist but permit BLM to take the more drastic measure of removing non-excess animals from the public lands altogether.

Finally, the Court notes that the original 1971 Act contained a provision that empowered the Secretary to destroy wild free-roaming horses or burros “when in his judgment such action is necessary to preserve and maintain the habitat in a suitable condition for continued use.” Pub. L. No. 92-195, § 3(c), 85 Stat. 649, 650 (Dec. 15, 1971). Congress repealed that provision in 1978 and replaced it with the current provision which speaks only to BLM’s authority to remove and destroy excess animals. See Pub. L. No. 95-514, § 14(a), 92 Stat. 1803, 1808 (Oct. 25, 1978); see also H.R. Rep. No. 95-1737, at 14 (1978) (“The conferees further agreed to retain the House bill’s mandate to the Secretaries to remove excess wild horses and burros from the public lands.”) (emphasis in original). The Court infers from that repeal that Congress intended to eliminate BLM’s discretion to destroy non-excess animals. Insofar as BLM’s decision to remove the West Douglas Herd makes the horses eligible for eventual destruction,19 the decision is contrary to Congress’s intent in the 1978 amendments to preclude BLM from destroying non-excess animals in order to maintain the habitat.

Defendants protest that because wild free-roaming horses will continue to inhabit the Piceance-East Douglas Herd Management Area, BLM’s decision to remove the West Douglas Herd will not result in the removal of all of the horses historically found in the Douglas Creek wild horse herd unit. See Defs.’ Reply at 7 (Plaintiffs cannot state a claim under the Wild Horse Act “because the BLM is not removing all horses from this historical range”). The argument misses the point. Defendants admit that “[t]he area of wild horse use at the passage of the Act was an area of 187,970 acres known as the ‘Douglas Creek wild horse herd unit,’” and that the herd unit encompassed the area that the West Douglas Herd now inhabits. Defs.’ Mem. at 14-15; see also Defs.’ Reply at 7 (“Defendants do not dispute that the administrative record reflects that some wild horses were present in 1974 in the area now known as the West Douglas H[erd] A[rea].”). That “BLM will continue to manage horses in the Douglas Creek herd unit because wild horses will be maintained in the Piceance-East Douglas HMA,” Defs.’ Mem. at 15, does nothing to remedy BLM’s lack of statutory authority to remove non-excess animals historically found in the Douglas Creek herd unit, including the West Douglas Herd Area.

IV. CONCLUSION

For the foregoing reasons, the Court finds that the 2008 Gather Plan was “in excess of statutory jurisdiction, authority, or limitations, or short of statutory right.”20 5 U.S.C. § 706(2)(C). A prerequisite to removal under the Wild Horse Act is that BLM first determine that an overpopulation exists and that the wild free-roaming horses and burros slated for removal are “excess animals.” BLM concededly has not made such a determination with respect to the horses in the West Douglas Herd Area. Accordingly, Plaintiffs’ motion for summary judgment will be granted in part, Defendants’ cross motion for summary judgment will be denied, and the 2008 Gather Plan will be set aside. A memorializing Order accompanies this Memorandum Opinion.

DATE: August 5, 2009

/s/ ROSEMARY M. COLLYER

United States District Judge

The entire story of our journey with horses (at least through early 2014) is told in the two books that follow: the national best seller The Soul of a Horse – Life Lessons from the Herd  and its sequel Born Wild – The Soul of a Horse.

And what a story it is as two novices without a clue stumble and bumble their way through the learning process so that hopefully you won’t have to. If you haven’t read both of these books already please do because with that reading, I believe, will come not just the knowledge of discovery but the passion and the excitement to cause you to commit to your journey with horses, to do for the horse without waiver so that your relationship and experience will be with loving, happy and healthy horses who are willing partners and who never stop trying for you. Horses like ours. 

The highly acclaimed best selling sequel to the National Best Seller
The Soul of a Horse – Life Lessons from the Herd

BornWild-FrontCover-Final325

#1 Amazon Best Seller
#1 Amazon “Hot New Releases”
Amazon & Kindle
B&N
Order Personally Inscribed Copies of Born Wild
Order Both The Soul of a Horse & Born Wild – Save 20%
Both Personally Inscribed
Please list the names for each inscription in the “instructions to Seller” field as you check out!
Read More About Born Wild
Read More About The Soul of a Horse
Watch The Soul of a Horse Trailer
Watch the  Born Wild Trailer

But first read the National Best Seller that started it all
Now in it’s 17th printing:

Amazon & Kindle
Barnes & Noble
Order Personally Inscribed Copies of The Soul of a Horse
Order Both The Soul of a Horse & Born Wild – Save 20%
Both Personally Inscribed
Please list the names for each inscription in the “instructions to Seller” field as you check out!
Read More About Born Wild
Read More About The Soul of a Horse
Watch The Soul of a Horse Trailer
Watch the  Born Wild Trailer
“Joe Camp is a master storyteller.” – The New York Times
“One cannot help but be touched by Camp’s love and sympathy for animals and by his eloquence on the subject.” – Michael Korda, The Washington Post
“Joe Camp is a natural when it comes to understanding how animals tick and a genius at telling us their story. His books are must-reads for those who love animals of any species.” – Monty Roberts – Author of New York Timers Best-seller The Man Who Listens to Horses
“Camp’s tightly-written, simply-designed and powerfully drawn chapters often read like short stories that flow from the heart.” Jack L. Kennedy – The Joplin Independent
“Joe Camp is a gifted storyteller and the results are magical. Joe entertains, educates and empowers, baring his own soul while articulating keystone principles of a modern revolution in horsemanship.” – Rick Lamb – TV/Radio host – The Horse Show
“One cannot help but be touched by Camp’s love and sympathy for animals and by his eloquence on the subject.” – Michael Korda, The Washington Post – See more at: https://thesoulofahorse.com/blog/the-books-of-joe-camp/born-wild-the-soul-of-a-horse/#sthash.6KJjzSLr.dpuf
“One cannot help but be touched by Camp’s love and sympathy for animals and by his eloquence on the subject.” – Michael Korda, The Washington Pos – See more at: https://thesoulofahorse.com/blog/the-books-of-joe-camp/born-wild-the-soul-of-a-horse/#sthash.6KJjzSLr.dpuf
“One cannot help but be touched by Camp’s love and sympathy for animals and by his eloquence on the subject.” – Michael Korda, The Washington Pos – See more at: https://thesoulofahorse.com/blog/the-books-of-joe-camp/born-wild-the-soul-of-a-horse/#sthash.6KJjzSLr.dpuf

Go to JoeCamp.info

The Soul of a Horse Video Channel on Vimeo

Visit The Soul of a Horse Channel on YouTube

 

Subscribe to our Blog. Enter your email address:

Delivered by FeedBurner

  • Read About Benji
Omega Nibblers Omega Horseshine WidBlog The Soul of a Horse Store The NAtural Horse Vet

DVDs and CDs

HD Widescreen Benji HD Widescreen For the Love of Benji DVD -The Original Benji - Written, produced & directed by Joe DVD - For the Love of Benji - Written, produced & directed by Joe DVD - Benji the Hunted - Written & directed by Joe DVD - Benji Off the Leash - Written & directed by Joe Benji Soundtrack CD CD - Inspiring Keynote Speech from Joe: Dare to Dream

Great Videos

  • 2-The Soul of a Horse Trailer
  • 2a-Relationship First!
  • 2b-Here We Go Again – Our Second Pregnant Mustang
  • 2c-First Romp in the Pasture for Saffron and Firestorm
  • 2d-Two Mustangs from the Wild and their First Trip into a New Paddock
  • 3: Our Paddock Paradise – What We Did, How We Did It, and Why
  • 4: Why our horses are barefoot
  • 5: Why our horses eat from the ground
  • 6: Our Rescue Miss Mouse – Two Years Later
  • 7: Horses Dancing Barefoot
  • 8: Benji gets a new baby… horse
  • 9: Benji Movie Memories
  • 9a-Rick Lamb Interviews Joe
  • Day 1 with Noelle – Loading at the BLM in Reno
  • Day 18- Don't Ask for Patience. God Will Give You a Horse!
  • Day 46 with Noelle
  • Day 70 with Noelle
  • Monty Roberts' Equus Online University
  • The Search for Benji in Shelters All Across the Country
  • The Soul of a Horse Channel on Vimeo
  • The Soul of a Horse Channel on YouTube

Hoof Care - Barefoot

  • 1-The Soul of a Horse Blog
  • 3: Our Paddock Paradise – What We Did, How We Did It, and Why
  • 4: Why our horses are barefoot
  • 7: Horses Dancing Barefoot
  • Eddie Drabek
  • Mark Taylor
  • Pete Ramey's Website

Mustangs

  • 1-The Soul of a Horse Blog
  • 2b-Here We Go Again – Our Second Pregnant Mustang
  • 2c-First Romp in the Pasture for Saffron and Firestorm
  • 2d-Two Mustangs from the Wild and their First Trip into a New Paddock
  • Day 1 with Noelle – Loading at the BLM in Reno
  • Day 18- Don't Ask for Patience. God Will Give You a Horse!
  • Day 46 with Noelle
  • Day 70 with Noelle
  • Ginger Kathren's The Cloud Foundation
  • ISPMB
  • The Soul of a Horse Channel on Vimeo
  • The Soul of a Horse Channel on YouTube

Natural Lifestyle

  • 1-The Soul of a Horse Blog
  • 2-The Soul of a Horse Trailer
  • 2c-First Romp in the Pasture for Saffron and Firestorm
  • 3: Our Paddock Paradise – What We Did, How We Did It, and Why
  • 6: Our Rescue Miss Mouse – Two Years Later
  • The Soul of a Horse Channel on Vimeo

Natural Training

  • 1-The Soul of a Horse Blog
  • 2a-Relationship First!
  • 2b-Here We Go Again – Our Second Pregnant Mustang
  • Imagine a Horse
  • Monty Roberts' Equus Online University
  • The Soul of a Horse Channel on Vimeo

Recommended Links

  • 1-The Soul of a Horse Blog
  • 2b-Benji Website
  • 9a-Rick Lamb Interviews Joe
  • Cowboy Dressage with Debbie & Eitan Halachmy
  • Crystal Peaks Youth Ranch
  • Eddie Drabek
  • Ginger Kathren's The Cloud Foundation
  • Horses of Proud Spirit Sanctuary
  • Imagine a Horse
  • ISPMB
  • Joe on Twitter
  • Mark Taylor
  • Monty Roberts' Equus Online University
  • Pete Ramey's Website

Relationship

  • 1-The Soul of a Horse Blog
  • 2-The Soul of a Horse Trailer
  • 2a-Relationship First!
  • 2b-Here We Go Again – Our Second Pregnant Mustang
  • 2d-Two Mustangs from the Wild and their First Trip into a New Paddock
  • Day 46 with Noelle
  • Day 70 with Noelle
  • The Soul of a Horse Channel on Vimeo
  • The Soul of a Horse Channel on YouTube

Terrific Horse Rescue Organizations

  • Animal Rescue League of Iowa
  • Horses of Proud Spirit Sanctuary

Terrific Pet Adoption Centers and Support

  • Animal Rescue League of Iowa
  • Helen Woodward Animal Center

Wild Horses

  • 1-The Soul of a Horse Blog
  • 2b-Here We Go Again – Our Second Pregnant Mustang
  • 2d-Two Mustangs from the Wild and their First Trip into a New Paddock
  • Day 1 with Noelle – Loading at the BLM in Reno
  • Day 46 with Noelle
  • Ginger Kathren's The Cloud Foundation
  • ISPMB
  • The Soul of a Horse Channel on Vimeo
  • Q&A with Joe
  • Our Former Place – The Birthplace of The Soul of a Horse
  • Our New Place in Middle Tennessee
  • Television & Radio Interviews
  • Read About the Houston Mounted Police Patrol – 40 Horses Working the Streets – All Barefoot!
  • Jack L. Kennedy Reviews Joe’s Books
  • The Soul of a Horse on Facebook

Joe & Kathleen

Barely eight years ago Joe and Kathleen Camp entered the world of horses without a horse or a clue and very quickly found their questions steering them into uncharted and controversial waters on a collision course with the ultimate discovery that most “domestic” horses in the world are being kept and cared for in a manner that is diametrically contradictory to their genetic design. Since that moment they have both become passionate advocates for change.

Kathleen is a lawyer specializing in litigation and is now teaching American Literature at The Webb School. Joe created the international canine superstar Benji and wrote, produced, and directed all five of the Benji movies and various television programs. His recent book The Soul of a Horse is a national best seller and in its ninth printing.

Even with all the accomplishments and media exposure, Camp is still in awe of his own success. “Inside, I’m still a kid sitting in a dark theater in Little Rock, Arkansas, watching Disney’s ‘Song of the South’ or reading books like the Black Stallion with happy tears rolling down my cheeks,” he says. “To be able to bringt that kind of happiness to others is very special.”

For more, click on the About Joe & Kathleen link in the header bar above.

The Soul of a Horse
Copyright © 2023 All Rights Reserved
iThemes Builder by iThemes
Powered by WordPress